Does This Sign Offer an Inferior Route to 202?
It tells drivers to turn right to get to Route 202 south, but left might be quicker.
Suppose you're driving north on Route 29 (Morehall Road), passing Uptown Worthington, and you want to head south on Route 202.
A sign posted on the overpass instructs you to turn right onto East Swedesford Road, but turning left will also get you to a Route 202 South entrance ramp. In fact, the ramp on the left is closer and drops you farther south on the highway.
So—why does the PennDOT sign recommend turning right, and driving past Penn State Great Valley?
We asked PennDOT spokeperson Gene Blaum, and here's the response we got:
I followed up by speaking to our Traffic Engineer. The distance appears to be about 400 feet shorter if you make a left from PA 29 NB onto WB Swedesford Road to access the ramp to SB US 202.The signs for SB US 202 South on NB Route 29 were originally installed in the 1990s because it is easier to accommodate larger volumes of traffic making a right turn than it is to make a left at an intersection, especially one with high traffic volumes like Route 29.
It is a rare situation where drivers have such a choice like they do at Route 29 and Swedesford Road, but it would be somewhat confusing to motorists to have signs pointing in both directions for ramps along Swedesford Road. Therefore, the right turn sign is used as it can handle the larger traffic volumes.
So, the right turn is better as a posted route for the bulk of traffic. But, if you're looking to save time during off-peak traffic, turning left onto West Swedesford Road might be a slightly quicker route to Route 202 South.
Lisa D
7:25 am on Sunday, November 11, 2012
Thanks for posting this article. Glad to know I'm not the only one who has wondered about this 202 sign. By the way, I ignore the signs and turn left to access 202 from 29.
hey becca
8:12 am on Sunday, November 11, 2012
Thank you for clarifying this issue.
Regina Fried
8:33 am on Sunday, November 11, 2012
I've always wondered about this, too. It's especially confusing for first-time visitors to our home who often ask how to head back via 202 North. We often get panicked phone calls, "There's a sign saying to turn right and you told us to turn left! What do we do?!"
Carter Rosemond
8:38 am on Sunday, November 11, 2012
I always turn right. Even though turning left would seem quicker, there is still turning left at that intersection to take into consideration. You can only turn left when there is an arrow. You aren't allow to turn left on green without the arrow, so may end up sitting there for a while. If you just missed the arrow, you still have to wait for the green cycle for traffic going N/S on 29. Then you have to wait for the green cycle for people turning left onto 29 from Swedesford, then you have to wait for the regular green light for Swedesford.
Dave Knies
3:55 pm on Sunday, November 11, 2012
When the GV Corporate Center was created, the road improvements were designed with a 'maximize right turs only' philosophy. As GVCC began to fill up, it became necessary to adjust signage, add left turns and ramps .... and generally adjust to the travel patterns. The beauty of this 'two paths' arrangement is that North bound 29 traffic can seek 202 via right turns .... and South bound 29 traffic can do the same.
Gene B. has got it right.
Dave Knies, Malvern